Mediation FAQ · Civil and insurance
Mediation vs. appraisal: what’s the difference?
By Faith Knight, Oklahoma Supreme Court Certified Civil and Family Mediator · Updated October 2026

The short answer
Appraisal is a process in many property policies that sets the amount of loss: each side picks an appraiser, and an umpire breaks ties. Mediation is a negotiation that can resolve the amount of loss and the harder questions too, like coverage and causation. Appraisal decides a number; mediation resolves the claim.
What appraisal is
Many homeowners and commercial property policies include an appraisal clause. When the parties disagree on the amount of loss, either can demand appraisal. Each side picks an appraiser, the appraisers choose an umpire, and an award signed by two of the three sets the amount. The policy language controls the details.
What mediation is
A confidential negotiation in which the policyholder, counsel and an adjuster with authority work through the dispute with a neutral mediator. Nothing is binding unless the parties sign an agreement.
The key differences
Scope: appraisal usually addresses only the amount of loss; mediation can take on coverage, causation, scope and amount together. Outcome: an appraisal award sets a number under the policy; a mediated agreement is whatever terms the parties accept, including payment timing and release language. Cost: appraisal means paying an appraiser and sharing an umpire; mediation means one shared mediator fee.
Which to use
If the only dispute is price, appraisal may be enough. If the carrier disputes what caused the damage, what the policy covers, or how the claim was handled, mediation can resolve what appraisal can’t. The two aren’t exclusive: some claims mediate first and go to appraisal only if the price gap remains.
Sources: This answer describes general practice. Your policy’s own language controls appraisal; counsel can advise on it. General information, not legal advice. Reviewed October 2026.
Keep reading: Storm, hail and property damage · Insurance mediation · Who needs settlement authority? · All mediation questions
Ready to schedule?
The scheduling form, an email to support@knightmediations.com, or a call to (512) 200-4215. Our scheduling coordinator replies within one business day.
Free guides: Your First Mediation · Divorce Mediation in Oklahoma · Custody and Parenting Plans · Insurance Claim Mediation in Oklahoma. Free worksheets: Schedule builder · Holiday planner · Asset and debt inventory. References: Mediation glossary · Family mediation glossary · Oklahoma family resources. No email required.
